Skip to content
MyNonRenewal
Check My Notice

Can't find homeowners insurance? Where to go next

Updated September 28, 2026· Sources verified September 28, 2026· Educational information, not legal advice

Short answer

Start with an independent agent who can check many insurers at once. If regular insurers decline, surplus lines insurers may offer coverage, and most states have a last-resort plan — the FAIR Plan in California and Texas, Citizens in Florida. Last-resort plans usually cover less, so compare carefully and start before your coverage ends.

Have your notice? Check it free

Your options, in the usual order

  1. Independent agent or broker

    Unlike a captive agent, they can quote several insurers. Tell them why you were non-renewed and bring your documents — roof invoices, repair receipts, mitigation work.

  2. Admitted insurers directly

    Some insurers sell directly. In Texas, the state's HelpInsure.com lets you compare sample rates and complaint records.

  3. Surplus lines insurers

    Licensed to write risks the regular market won't. Rates and forms are less regulated, and state guaranty funds usually don't cover them — read the policy closely.

  4. Your state's last-resort plan

    FAIR Plans and Citizens exist for homes that can't get regular coverage. They often provide narrower coverage, and eligibility rules apply.

State last-resort plans

California FAIR Plan

Fire-focused policy; add a separate policy for liability, theft and water damage.

Florida Citizens

Eligibility depends on private offers (the 20% rule) and home value.

Texas FAIR Plan & TWIA

Two declinations required; TWIA covers wind in coastal areas.

Improve your chances

  • Fix the stated reason if you can (roof, brush, debris) and keep dated proof.
  • Ask about mitigation discounts — California requires insurers to offer them for Safer from Wildfires work.
  • Consider a higher deductible to widen your options.
  • Keep copies of declinations; the Texas FAIR Plan requires two.

Want to know what applies to your notice?

Upload the letter and we'll check its dates and reason against your state's published rules — free.

Check My Notice Free

Watch the gap

Make sure new coverage starts on or before your current coverage ends. A gap can trigger insurance bought by your mortgage servicer. How that works.

Official sources

Rules can change. Check the official source before relying on it.

Want to know what applies to your specific notice?

Upload your letter and MyNonRenewal will check the dates, the reason and your state's rules — free, with the official source for each rule.

Check My Notice Free See a sample report

MyNonRenewal provides educational information and document summaries. It does not provide legal advice, insurance advice, representation, or recommendations regarding specific insurance products.