Skip to content
MyNonRenewal

My home insurance company dropped me. What do I do now?

Updated September 28, 2026· Sources verified September 26, 2026· Educational information, not legal advice

Short answer

Start with the coverage end date — that is your real deadline. Then check the notice against your state's rules, ask for the specific reason if it isn't clear, and start shopping for replacement coverage right away, even if you plan to ask the insurer to reconsider. Tell your mortgage servicer if you have one.

Have your notice? Check it free

Being dropped by your insurer is stressful, but in most cases you have weeks or months to respond. These are the steps people commonly take, in roughly the order they take them.

In the first few days

  1. Find the coverage end date

    Add reminders at 30 and 14 days before it.
  2. Keep the letter and the envelope

    The postmark can show when it was mailed, which can matter for the notice period.
  3. Check the notice period

    Compare the days between the notice date and the end date with your state's published rule. Our free notice check does this and links the official source.
  4. Read the reason carefully

    Is it about your property, your claims, or the insurer's business?
  5. Tell your mortgage servicer

    Most mortgages require continuous coverage.

In the next two to three weeks

  1. Ask for the details behind the decision

    Request any inspection report, photos or claim records the decision relied on. Some states give you a formal right to this — in California, for example, a written request within 90 business days.
  2. Gather documents

    Declarations page, receipts, permits, photos, and your claims history report if claims were mentioned.
  3. Decide whether to ask for reconsideration

    Worth doing when the reason is about your property and you can show it is wrong or has been fixed. See can you appeal a non-renewal?
  4. Start collecting quotes

    An independent agent can check several insurers at once. Start early — in some markets fewer insurers are writing new policies.

Want to know what applies to your notice?

Upload the letter and we'll check its dates and reason against your state's published rules — free.

Check My Notice Free

Before the coverage end date

  1. Compare offers on coverage, not just price

    Check deductibles (including wind/hail or hurricane deductibles), exclusions and roof payment terms.
  2. Look at your state's last-resort option if needed

    FAIR Plans, Citizens and similar programs exist for homes that can't get regular coverage. See can't find homeowners insurance.
  3. Make sure the new policy starts on or before the old one ends

    Send proof of coverage to your mortgage servicer so it does not buy insurance for you.

If you have a mortgage

If your servicer believes you have no coverage, it can buy insurance for you and charge you — after sending notices at least 45 and 15 days before charging. That insurance often costs more and covers less. See what happens with your mortgage.

If you have questions about the notice

Your state Department of Insurance answers questions for free and can look into complaints. For individual advice, a licensed insurance professional or attorney may be appropriate. State guides: California, Florida and Texas.

Official sources

Rules can change. Check the official source before relying on it.

Want to know what applies to your specific notice?

Upload your letter and MyNonRenewal will check the dates, the reason and your state's rules — free, with the official source for each rule.

MyNonRenewal provides educational information and document summaries. It does not provide legal advice, insurance advice, representation, or recommendations regarding specific insurance products.